You turn on your tap, fill a glass, and wonder what’s really in that water. Maybe you’ve noticed a metallic taste, or you’re concerned about contaminants like fluoride, lead, or PFAS that standard filters miss. If you’re looking for a water filter pitcher that delivers genuine peace of mind, you’ve come to the right place. In this review, we compare two popular models: the Clearly Filtered Water Filter Pitcher and the Reshape Water 10-Cup Pitcher with 6-Stage Filter. We’ll help you decide which one fits your needs and budget. For a broader look at top options, check out our guide on the best water filter pitcher for fluoride.
Buying Guide
Contaminant Removal
Not all filters are created equal. The Clearly Filtered pitcher uses Affinity Filtration Technology to target over 386 contaminants, including fluoride, lead, arsenic, and microplastics, with up to 99.99% reduction. It is NSF certified for chlorine taste and odor and lead-free materials. In contrast, the Reshape Water pitcher removes fluoride, chlorine, lead, and VOCs through a 6-stage process that also alkalizes water. If you are concerned about a wide range of pollutants, Clearly Filtered offers broader coverage. For more on fluoride-specific options, see our best water filter pitcher for fluoride article.
Filter Life and Cost
Long filter life means fewer replacements and lower long-term cost. The Clearly Filtered pitcher lasts up to 100 gallons (about 4 months), while the Reshape Water filter lasts up to 79 gallons (about 75 days). Reshape Water claims its replacement filters cost 25% to 33% less than comparable brands, making it a more budget-friendly choice over time. However, Clearly Filtered’s longer lifespan may appeal to users who prefer less frequent swapping.
Build Quality and Materials
Both pitchers use BPA-free plastics, but the Clearly Filtered model goes a step further with medical-grade Tritan plastic that is free from BPS and endocrine disruptors. It also features a spill-resistant water dam and ergonomic handle. The Reshape Water pitcher uses thick, sturdy ABS plastic designed for daily use and fits easily in a refrigerator. If material safety is a top priority, Clearly Filtered’s medical-grade construction stands out.
Additional Features
The Reshape Water pitcher not only filters but also raises pH and adds beneficial minerals like magnesium, potassium, and calcium, creating alkaline water with antioxidant properties. This may appeal to those seeking health benefits beyond simple filtration. The Clearly Filtered pitcher focuses solely on contaminant removal while preserving beneficial minerals naturally present in water. For a comparison of other pitcher options, read our ZeroWater 10 cup pitcher review.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between these two pitchers comes down to your priorities. If maximum contaminant removal with medical-grade materials is non-negotiable, go with the Clearly Filtered Water Filter Pitcher. If you want an affordable filter that also alkalizes water and adds minerals, the Reshape Water 10-Cup Pitcher with 6-Stage Filter is a solid choice that won’t break the bank. Both are reliable options for cleaner, better-tasting water at home.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often do I need to replace the filter in a Clearly Filtered pitcher?
The Clearly Filtered filter lasts up to 100 gallons or about 4 months, depending on usage. When the water flow slows noticeably, it’s time for a swap. Replacement filters are available through the brand’s subscription service.
Does the Reshape Water pitcher really remove fluoride?
Yes, the Reshape Water 6-stage filter is designed to reduce fluoride, along with chlorine, lead, and VOCs. It has been independently verified by a US-based laboratory and holds SGS certification for its claims.
Can I use these pitchers with well water?
Both pitchers are intended for municipal tap water. If you have well water, you should have it assessed for specific contaminants like bacteria or sediment that these filters may not address. For more on filtration options, see our best water filter pitcher for fluoride guide.
Which pitcher is better for removing PFAS?
The Clearly Filtered pitcher specifically targets PFAS/PFOA and removes them at up to 99.99% efficiency. The Reshape Water pitcher does not list PFAS in its reduction claims, so Clearly Filtered is the better choice if PFAS is a concern.
